Utility of Phatak Repertory in Acute Diseases

Utility of Phatak Repertory in Acute Diseases

ABSTRACT:

Background: The term acute disease defines that it is rapidly progressive and always complete its course more or less quickly. For the treatment of acute disease recently altered symptoms weather they are mental, general and physical should be considered to furnish the totality. Phatak repertory is very concise and convenient clinical repertory to use as it is arranged alphabetically. The good part of Phatak repertory is it contains many clinical and pathological rubrics and all the medicines it contains were used by author himself. Phatak repertory is very useful in cases which are full of general symptoms or we can do generalization of available symptom and use it.

Objective: To study the utility of Phatak repertory in acute diseases. To manage the acute diseases with Phatak repertory. To study the Phatak repertory and prescribed on the base of individualization.

Results: Results were categorised into 3 category like significantly

improved, improved and status quo. Out of 50, 80% significantly improved, 14% improved and 6% cases are status quo.

Conclusion: Phatak repertory is concise and alphabetically arranged handy clinical repertory. It is very feasible to use for the acute disease as it contains more clinical and pathological rubrics.

Key words: Phatak repertory , acute diseases

Introduction:

Disease is considered as the state of disharmonious functioning of vital force, which is manifested by loss of sense of well-being.1 Dr Hahnemann defined acute disease as – “the disease to which man is liable are either rapid, morbid processes of the abnormally deranged vital force, which have a tendency to finish their course more or less quickly but always in moderate time.”Dr Hahnemann classify acute disease in – individual, sporadic and epidemic.2

During the treatment of acute disease main aim of the physician is to accelerate the natural defense mechanism. Physician has to prescribe only on the present acute totality.3

In acute disease it may be possible that remedy may change very soon, followed by either patient may cure and do not require any other medicine or it will back to background chronic totality.3 The management of the remedy in regard to potency and dose is as important as the selection of remedy.4

Materia medica is the ever enlarging subject and it is not possible to memories all the available symptoms, so to solve this problem repertory was born. The repertory is an outcome of the logical human mind. Numerous repertories has come since Dr Hahnemann’s era till now, they are classify according to their philosophical background and use. 5

Phatak repertory is concise, clinical and alphabetically arranged repertory which is published in 1963 by Dr S.R. PHATAK. It is based on the “Repertory part of synoptic key to materia medica” by C. M. Borer. It contains innumerable addition both in the rubrics and remedies, so that it is like enlarged and improvised version of the “synoptic key.” The addition made by Dr S. R. Phatak are from the authenticity sources like Kent, BTPB, etc. and also from his case taking and clinical observations. 6

OBJECTIVE:

To study the utility of Phatak repertory in acute disease

To manage the acute disease with Phatak repertory

To study the Phatak repertory

MATERIALS AND METHODOLOGY:

The present study was conducted at Ahmedabad Homeopathic Medical College & Sainath Hospital, Bopal Ghuma Road, Ahmedabad.

MATERIALS:

  • Project site: Ahmedabad Homoeopathic Medical College & Sainath Hospital.
  • Number of cases: 50
  • Duration of year: 1 year

METHODS:

A detailed case history was taken according to the model case record format with special emphasis to ascertain the following:

  • History of present complaints, past history, family history, personal history: Present complaints with their duration and the associated was recorded very keenly because in acute recent alteration which is very useful for the prescription. Past history was recorded to know any chronic tendency. Maternal and paternal family history was taken to know the hereditary causes and mostly useful in cases of acute exacerbation. All the general symptoms of the patients were very keenly recorded because recently altered generals were very helpful for prescription.

Medical examination:

  • General and systemic examination: positive findings were noted.
  • Investigation: all the required investigations were included and noted as per the case required.
  • Diagnosis: from clinical examination and investigations.

SELECTION OF TOOLS:

  • Homoeopathic Repertory: A concise repertory of homoeopathic medicine by DR S.R.PHATAK7 

INCLUSION CRITERIA:

          Acute cases were randomly selected irrespective of age, sex, socio-economic condition.

EXCLUSION CRITERIA:

  • Acute cases advanced and irreversible pathological conditions.
  • Cases with irregular follow up.
  • Acute surgical emergency
  • Medico legal cases
  • Any acute disease condition which requires an emergency modern medicines.

STUDY DESIGN: Experimental

ADMINISTRATION OF MEDICINES:

Required potency, dose and repetition was selected according to homoeopathic principles. All the medicines was administered through oral route.

FOLLOW UP: As per the requirement and intensity of cases.

ANALYSIS AND RESULTS:

Criteria for result:

  1. Significant improvement – Disappearance of all the sign and symptoms with no recurrence.
  2. Improved: Decrease in intensity and / or frequency of presenting complaints with feeling of well-being.
  3. Status quo – Neither increase nor decrease in the symptoms of the patient.

CONCLUSION:

It is based on outcome of result on the basis of material and method.

Results:

Age incidences

Age Number of patients Percentage (%)
0-10 3 6%
10-20 15 30%
20-30 13 26%
30-40 5 10%
40-50 6 12%
50-60 8 16%
Total 50 100%

Table 1:  presenting age group and percentage of total no. of patients

Figure 1: Bar graph presenting age demographic incidences

Gender incidences

Gender Number of patients Percentage (%)
Female 22 44%
Male 28 56%
Total 50 100%

Table: 2 presenting gender distribution

Figure: 2 pie chart present comparison of gender distribution

Clinical conditions wise distribution

Clinical Conditions No of patients Percentage (%)
Acute Bronchitis 5 10%
Acute Gastritis 3 6%
Acute Gastro enteritis 5 10%
Acute otitis media 5 10%
Acute tonsillitis 5 10%
Dengue 10 20%
Food poisoning 2 4%
Urinary tract infection 5 10%
viral fever 10 20%
Grand Total 50 100%

Table 3: presenting various acute clinical conditions in different no. of patients and percentage

Figure 3: pie chart presenting various acute clinical conditions distribution

System wise distribution

Different Systems No. of Patients Percentage (%)
Infectious Diseases 20 40%
Digestive System 10 20%
Auditory System 5 10%
Urinary System 5 10%
Respiratory System 10 20%
Total 50 100%

Table 4: presenting system wise distribution in no. of patients and percentage

Figure 4: Doughnut pie chart present system wise distribution

Remedy distribution

 
Medicine No of case % Medicine No of case %
Eupatorium Perfoliatom 5 10% Cantharis 3 6%
Arsenicum Album 5 10% Phosphorus 2 4%
Mercurius Solubilis 1 2% Gelsemium 5 10%
Belladonna 4 8% Bryonia 2 4%
Lachesis 1 2% Colocynthis 2 4%
opium 1 2% Hepar sulphuris 1 2%
Nux Vomica 3 6% Veretrum Album 1 2%
China Officinalis 3 6% Aconite 1 2%
Antimonium Tartricum 2 4% Mercurius Iodatus Flavum 1 2%
Pulsatilla 3 6% Podophyllum 1 2%
Mercurius Iodatus Ruber 2 4%      
Apis Mellifica 1 2% Total 50 100%

Table 5: present various homoeopathic remedies used for the treatment of acute diseases with percentage

Figure 5: column chart present remedy distribution

Potency distribution

Potency No. of. Patients Percentage (%)
30c 26 52%
200c 22 44%
1M 2 4%
Total 50 100%

Table 6: present various potency used in the study for no. of patients with percentage

Remarks

Remarks Number of patients Percentage (%)
Improved 7   14%
significantly Improved 40   80%
Status Quo 3   6%
Total 50   100%

Table 7: present treatment result of 50 patient

Figure 6: pie chart present improvement results

DISCUSSION:

The study was conducted at Ahmedabad homeopathic medical college and Sainath hospital, to prove the utility of Phatak repertory in acute disease. Total 50 acute cases were selected for the study. All 50 cases were analyzed with Phatak repertory. Selected acute cases were of different age groups, irrespective of both gender. Only those acute cases were included who don’t required any emergency treatment. The cases were diagnosed on the clinical presentation as well as investigation as per the case demands.

The cases were repertories from the Phatak repertory. Assessment was done before treatment and after treatment. Follow up was taken as per the case required. The statistical analysis were calculated and interpreted. Cases were analysed on the bases of age distribution, gender distribution, clinical condition wise distribution, system wise distribution, various remedies distribution, potency distribution and remarks.

In this study of 50 patients were selected from all the age groups out of that highest incidence noted in age group 10-20 years which is 30% (15 patients), then in the age group of 20 – 30 years which is 26% (13 patients), after that in 50-60 years which is 16% (8 patients), then in the age group of 40-50 years which is 10% (6 patients), after that age group of 30-40 years which is 10% (5 patients), then in the age group of 0-10 years which is 6% (3 patients).

For this study, cases were selected from both genders out of that 56% (28 patients) males and 44% (22 patients) females.

This study contains various acute diseases out of that highest incidences is of viral fever as well as dengue which is 20% (10 patients), after that acute gastro enteritis, urinary tract infection, acute tonsillitis and acute otitis media which is of 10% (5 patients), then acute gastritis occurs in 6% (3 patients) and lowest incidence is of food poisoning which is 4% (2 patients).

In this study, various acute diseases includes from various system of the body, the highest incidences is of infectious diseases which are 40% (20 patients), then from digestive system and respiratory system 20% (10 patients), after that from the urinary system and auditory system 10% (5 patients).

Remedies were prescribed on the basis of individuality after repertorisation from Phatak repertory. Numerousremedies were used to treat acute diseases out of that highest used remedies are Eupatorium perfoliatum, Gelsemium sempervirens and Arsenicum album in the 10 % (5 patients), after that Belladonna is used in 8% (4 patients) cases, then Nux vomica, China officinalis, Pulsatilla nigircans and Cantharis vesicatoria in 6% (3 patients), after that Antimonium tartaricum, Mercurius iodatus ruber, Phosphorus, Bryonia alba and Colocynthis used in 4% (2 patients), then Mercurius Solubilis, Lachesis mutus, Opium, Apis mellifica, Hepar sulphuris, Veratrum album, Aconitum napellus, Mercurius iodatus flavum used in 2% (1 patient).

In this study, many suitable different potencies were used as per the guidelines given in Organon of medicine out of that maximum used potency is 30c for the 52% (26 patients), then 200c potency used for 44% (22 patients), minimum used potency is 1M is for 4% (2 patients).

Conclusion:  As we know that no repertory is perfect all the repertory has its own utility like that Phatak repertory contains more general symptoms, even we can’t find particular symptom we can make it general. Here all the rubrics arranged alphabetically so sometimes it is difficult to find out mental symptoms. We can sometimes find difficulties when case is full of particulars.

At the end of the study significantly improved cases are 80% (40 patients), improved cases are 14% (7 patients) and status quo show in 6% (3 patients).

Thus, from the above observation, one can draw the conclusion that Phatak repertory is useful to solve the acute diseases. As it is alphabetically arranged so it is very feasible to use and convenient to carry at bed side. Phatak repertory cannot replace the exhaustive repertories as it contains very few sub-rubrics and very few medicines for the same. So in the cases which contain more general symptoms, Phatak repertory is very useful, or one can take particular symptom and make it general like, “pulsating pain in head” one can find in Phatak repertory as pain: pulsating. With a very few sub-rubrics and medicines, one can opt very wonderful results. Another good part of Phatak repertory is that it contains only those medicines which were used by author himself.

References:

  1. DHAWALE M. L. – Principles & Practice of Homoeopathy, (Fourth Edition), New Delhi, B. Jain Publishers (P) L.td, 2014, p. 9, 37, 4.
  2. SARKAR B. K. – Organon of medicine, (tenth reprinted edition), Delhi, Birla Publication (P) L.td, 2010, p. 160,161,326,378.
  3. Vitholkas G. – The science of homoeopathy, (reprint edition), New Delhi, B. Jain publishers (P) L. td, 1993, p. 187-189.
  4. Close S. – The genius of homoeopathy lectures and essays on homoeopathic philosophy, (reprinted edition), Indian books and periodical publishers, 2014, p. 191, 202.
  5. Tiwari S. K. – essentials of repertorization (fifth edition), New Delhi, B. Jain publishers (P) L.td, 2012, p. 13, 14, 29, 8, 15, 20, 486
  6. Khanaj R. V. – Reperire, (fifth revised and added edition), New Delhi, Indian books and periodical publishers, (P) L. td, 2002, p. 891    
  • Phatak S. R. – A concise repertory of homoeopathic medicine alphabetically arranged (fourth edition), New Delhi, B. Jain publishers (P) L.td, 2005
Homeopathy360 Team
Posted By: Homeopathy360 Team