Symptomatic Treatment in Heart Failure with Homoeopathic Medicine - A Case Study

Symptomatic Treatment in Heart Failure with Homoeopathic Medicine – A Case Study

Homoeopathic Medicine

ABSTRACT: The main aim of this article is to understand the efficacy of Homoeopathic medicines in the management of patients with heart failure and improve their quality of life.

Keywords: Symptom, syndrome, Dyspnoea, oedema, Systemic, PND, Orthopnoea, Anorexia


The nature of energy is dynamic, and this dynamis penetrates every particle, every cell, and every atom of the human economy. Any disturbance of this vital energy or force results in a disfigured or disturbed development of the whole human economy.1 Heart failure is a syndrome of ventricular dysfunction. HF affects about 5 million people in us. More than 500,000 new cases occur in each year2. As Dr Hahnemann says, the totality of symptoms is the outwardly reflected picture of the internal essence of the disease. Whereby the disease can make known what remedy it requires.3


In HF the heart may not be provided tissues with adequate blood for metabolic needs and cardiac-related elevation of pulmonary or systemic venous pressure may result in organ congestion. This condition can result from abnormalities of systolic or diastolic function. or commonly both.

Systolic dysfunction: In systolic dysfunction, the ventricle contract poorly and empties inadequately.

Diastolic dysfunction: Ventricular filling is impaired. Resulting in reduced ventricular–end–diastolic volume.

LVF:  It is due to LV dysfunction. CO decreases and pulmonary capillary pressure increases. When pulmonary capillary pressure exceeds the oncotic pressure of plasma protein . So fluid extravasates from the capillaries into the interstitial space and alveoli which leads to pulmonary oedema causing dyspnoea.

RVF: Failure due to RV dysfunction. Systemic venous pressure increases causing fluid extravasation and consequent oedema primarily independent tissue.2

Signs and symptoms

Dyspnoea – Exertional


If HF worsens dyspnoea can occur during rest and at night also

Nocturnal cough

Orthopnoea – In advanced HF

PND, Ankle swelling, the fullness of the abdomen and neck

Right upper quadrant abdominal discomfort

Anorexia and abdominal bloating


Clinical evaluation

Chest –Xray

Echocardiography, ECG 2


The patient named Mr AF 66 yr old male came with the complaint of breathlessness, cough and chest pain for 5 yrs increased since 1 month

Location Sensation  Modality Accompaniment
Respiratory system Since 5 yrs Increased since 1 month           chest Breathlessness++ Cough with whitish expectoration    pain <  lying down++ <  night++ <  exertion ++ <  walking >  sitting upright     Debility   Swelling of legs


The patient is k/c/o DM for 20 years and hypertensive for 2 years. 5 years back patient developed a complaint of breathlessness for a considerable period of time .Then started coughing with frothy expectoration, followed by chest pain. The breathlessness is more during the night, lying down and exertion and better by sitting upright. Gradually he developed swelling in the b/l legs and pain which limited his walking ability to a great extent

There is no history of syncope, radiation of pain to arms, hemoptysis, and palpitations.


Past medical history: Malaria

Past surgical history: Surgery done following RTA

Past treatment history: Allopathic medication after an accident

Allergic history: Not allergic to drugs, dust, and diet.


Diet: Mixed

Appetite: Decreased

Thirst: Thirsty

Bowel: once/week

Bladder: 3-4t/D 1t/N

Thermals: Hot patient

Perspiration: generalized

Sleep: disturbed at night


Well-oriented with time, place, and person

Well Built and well nourished

No signs of Pallor, Cyanosis, Clubbing, Icterous, Lymphadenopathy

B/L pitting pedal oedema present up to the knee with blackish discolouration.

Vitals: RR-22bpm, PR- 78bpm, BP- 150/80mmhg, Temp: Afebrile


Chest and precordium


No scar mark, visible pulsation

Chest is b/l symmetrical

Type of respiration: Abdomino – thoracic respiration


No tenderness

Tactile vocal fremitus: felt b/l lung field

Chest expansion: < 1cm

Transverse diameter:

Inspiration -12.5 inch 

Expiration- 12 inch

AP diameter :Inspiration-7.7 inch    Expiration-7.5 inch

Apex beat: a palpable, minimal shift towards the mid-axial line

Percussion: Resonant heard bilaterally

Cardiac dullness from 2nd to 5th ics

Liver dullness: 5th to 8th ics

Auscultation: Crepitation heard on left side infra clavicular and supra mammary region

Congestive cardiac failure  Bronchial asthma
Breathlessness Cough Chest pain PND Orthopneoa b/l pedal edema Breathlessness Cough PND R/o Orthopneoa ,chest pain, b/l pedal edema are prominent in this pt so Bronchial asthma is ruled out


Breathlessness ++     

 < lying down++             

Chest pain +                 

< night++             

< exertion++

< walking

> Sitting upright

Cough with whitish expectoration


Swelling in the legs

Considering the pathological state and symptom similarity medicine selected was Strophanthus hispidus.4


1. Strophanthus Q     5o– 0 – 5o

                For 2 week


1. Breathlessness < night

    < lying down, < exertion

2. Cough with scanty whitish expectoration

3. Chest pain

4. Weakness

5. Pedal oedema

6. Appetite

7. Sleep

Breathlessness Cough with scanty expectoration Chest pain Weakness Pedal edema Appetite Sleep
         D  D D   D    D    D G


All the perceptible signs represent the disease to its whole extent, that is, together they form the true and only conceivable portrait of the disease.3In incurable cases we should not put a limitation on the possibilities of a similar remedy, for in many seemingly incurable conditions the similimum will so completely meet the situation as to obliterate the symptomatology of disease and the pathology as well. Finding out what is there to be cured inpatient is the art of a Homoeopathic physician and this is how we can improve the quality of life of the patient. REFERENCE

  1. Robert H.A, The Principles and Art of Cure by Homoeopathy, 11th edition, B.Jain p.LTD, 2012.
  2. Porter .S. Robert , The Merck Manual, 19th edition, Pg: 2118- 2131
  3. Hahnemann s, Organon of medicine,8th edition, B.Jain p.LTD,2014,Pg:33
  4. Boericke W, Pocket manual of Homoeopathic Materia Medica & Repertory, 10th edition,B.Jain.P.LTD, 2012.Pg: 615


1. Dr Ashlin Augustine, M D Scholer

Father Muller Homoeopathic Medical College and Hospital

Department of Organon of Medicine and Homoeopathic Philosophy

Posted By

Homeopathy360 Team