Keywords
Observer, Unprejudiced, Case taking, Physician
Abstract
Observation is a critical yet often underemphasized component of homeopathic case taking. Beyond patient history, careful attention to physical appearance, demeanor and involuntary expressions can reveal characteristic signs essential for accurate remedy selection. This article highlights a physician’s role as an unprejudiced observer, understanding how subtle, non-verbal cues complement verbal narratives to form complete, individualized case pictures. “A great part, I believe, of the art is to be able to observe”, says Hippocrates in his aphorisms.
Keywords: Observer, Unprejudiced, Case taking, Physician
Introduction
Derived from Latin observare (“to watch over”), observation uses multiple senses in an active process of recognition. It goes beyond merely seeing and hearing; it is a skill that takes time to develop. Observation is integral to initial case taking and follow-up visits, standing alongside listening, interrogation, and clinical examination as a core pillar.
What is observation?
The word “observation” is derived from Latin –“observare” -to watch over, note, heed, attend to. Observation goes beyond merely seeing and hearing, it is an art form and a skill that takes time to experience, develop and refine. Observation acts as the core pillar in case taking.
Case taking
Case taking is defined as the meticulous collection of information about a patient through various means, including observation, history gathering, and examination, with the primary goal of uncovering the “totality of symptoms” experienced by the patient.
Homoeopath’s observation
The physician should note:
- Whether he or she was in a drowsy state or in any way dull of comprehension.
- Whether he or she spoke hoarsely or in a low tone or how otherwise he or she talk.
- What was the colour of his or her face and eyes and of his or her skin generally.
- What degree of liveliness and power was there in his or her expression and eyes.
- What was the state of his or her tongue, his or her breathing, the smell from his or her mouth and his or her hearing.
- Were his or her pupils dilated or contracted? How rapidly and to what extent did they alter in the dark and in light.
- What effort did he or she make to raise himself or herself
- Personality of the patient
- His/her apparent state of mind (both in himself/herself and in relation to the doctor) whether depressed, shy, suspicious, secretive, afraid, ashamed etc.
- His/her apparent physical status (signs of disease in gait, complexion, difficulty in breathing, etc.).
- Traits of character as shown in dress, cleanliness, neatness, pride, etc.
- How the patient behaved during the visit. Whether he or she was morose, quarrelsome, hasty, tearful, anxious, despairing or sad or hopeful and calm etc.
- How the patient sits, answers, talks, behaves etc. during interrogation?
Key guidelines for pediatric case-taking in homeopathy
In pediatric homeopathy, practitioners often rely on both Objective symptoms and behavioral observations to determine the most appropriate remedy. While physical symptoms are crucial, children’s behaviors, interactions, and developmental history often reveal deeper insights into their health.
1. Behavioral observation: crying, irritability, lethargy, mood swings.
2. Interaction with caregivers: comfort-seeking patterns can suggest remedies (e.g., Arsenicum album prefers being carried when anxious).
3. Position of sleep: certain postures correspond to remedies (e.g., Medorrhinum for prone sleeping).
4. Mother’s observations – jealousy, social behavior, pregnancy history, and developmental traits provide valuable insights.
This exhaustive approach is fundamental to the individualized nature of homeopathic treatment.
- Comprehensive Patient Profile: Physicians record demographic details, occupation, marital status, physical description, and personal/family health history. They assess the present illness, onset, duration, changes, prior treatments, and vaccination history.
- Mental and Emotional Landscape: Mental symptoms are paramount. Observation covers dispositional changes—mildness, irritability, gloom, cheerfulness—and desires (for company, solitude, or death). Also noted are confusion, delirium, discontent, and disgust.
Objective Signs and Physical Examination
This involves a thorough visual examination of the patient’s posture, movement, hands, face, and body, including skin. General observations cover aspects such as the patient’s sex, apparent age, constitution, posture, state of nutrition, facies (facial expression), and manner of dress and talking. Specific physical findings are noted, such as styes or chalazae on eyelids, eruptions on covered parts, sweat on uncovered parts, or a tendency to small, painful boils. Other physical observations include gait, extremities, general stooped shoulders, discoloration (pale, anemic, icteric, cyanotic skin), perspiration (general/particular, odor), lymph nodes (indurations, swelling), pulse, blood pressure, temperature, and respiration. Observations of the sick room can also provide therapeutic hints, such as open windows in cold weather indicating a desire for open air, or a preference for dim light/darkness/solitude.
Hahnemann’s Mandate: The “Unprejudiced Observer”
Samuel Hahnemann, in his Organon of Medicine, establishes the physician’s “high and only mission” as restoring the sick to health. To achieve this, the physician must perceive the “true and only conceivable portrait of the disease” through observable symptoms. Aphorism 6 is fundamental to this concept, stating that the “unprejudiced observer” notices only the deviations from the former healthy state, as felt by the patient, remarked by those around him, and observed by the physician. A crucial instruction from Hahnemann (Aphorism 87) is to avoid suggestive questioning, as framing questions to suggest answers can mislead patients and result in untrue or affirmative/negative responses that are “something untrue”. The physician should generally keep silent and not interfere during the patient’s narrative unless they wander off topic, advising them to speak slowly. Hahnemann in his “Medical observer” writes, “True is, that the careful observer alone can become a true healer of disease”.
Importance of observation in case taking according to Dr.H.A.Robert
I have left until the last mention of the essential part of the case-taking, the comprehension of the mental symptoms. To a great extent these are symptoms that must be observed from the attitude of the patient. Find if they are subject to hallucinations or fixed ideas, especially any fears that are persistent. Take into consideration irritability, or a change in disposition; if you can unearth traits of jealousy, or absent-mindedness, these must be seriously considered. Sadness, ailments arising from grief, vexation, sudden joy, are important. Is the patient over-insistent upon the minor details of life as to scrupulous cleanliness, etc.
Importance of observation in case taking according to Dr. J.T.Kent
It is important for the physician to know the value of expressions. The physician must know immediately upon entering the room what the state of the patient resembles: apoplexy, coma, opium poisoning, etc. A physician is supposed to set his mind to work instantly, to ascertain the condition of the patient and what relation the symptoms maintain to the Materia Medica.
“If the homoeopathic physician is not an accurate observer, his observations will be indefinite, his prescribing is indefinite.”
Importance of observation in case taking according to Dr.Stuart Close
Pathology and diagnosis do not seek for nor take into consideration the phenomena which are most significant from the standpoint of the homœopathic prescriber. The technique of an examination for the purpose of diagnosing the disease is quite different from that of the examination for making the homœopathic prescription. The purpose of the homœopathic exomination is to bring out the symptoms of the patient in such a way as to permit their comparison with the symptoms of the materia medica for the purpose of selecting the similar or homœopathic remedy.
If the patient is confined to bed, the examiner will observe his position in bed, his manner of moving or turning, his respiration, the state of his skin, color or odor of perspiration, odor of exhalations from mouth or body, physical appearance of excretions, relation of the patient’s sensations to atmosphere and temperature is shown in amount of covering, ventilation of room, ice bags, hot water bottle, etc., all these, and many other little points, noticeable by the alert examiner, perhaps without asking a question, will be valuable guides in the choice of the remedy.
Expertness in observing and analyzing these features of disease should be cultivated because right conclusions and effective treatment often depend more upon the physician’s own observations and directions, than upon any-thing that others or even the patient are able to tell him. In the matter of mood or temper of the mind, for instance, he will be able to judge from the patient’s manner of relating or expressing his sufferings and his behavior toward his attendants, whether he is sad or cheerful; calm or anxious, confident or afraid, indifferent, morose, censorious, malicious, irritable, suspicious, or jealous.
As to the intellect, he can observe for himself whether the patient is dull, stupid, unconscious, excited, delirious, distracted, confused, etc.
Non-Verbal Cues and Demeanor
Body language during consultation—avoiding eye contact, exclusive communication with the doctor, restlessness—offers insights into emotional states like secrecy, trauma, or inner conflict. Sleep postures, limb positions, and behaviors such as talking or walking in sleep are also important.
Uncovering the Totality of Symptoms
Observation adds objective data to subjective reports, often revealing peculiarities the patient omits. This is vital for withdrawn or timid individuals who under-report symptoms.
Understanding Peculiarities and Individualization
Observations help identify traits deviating from cultural norms, crucial for selecting the simillimum. Physical constitution (e.g., “fat, fair, and flabby” for Calcarea carbonica) can provide broad clues, refined through specific behaviors or preferences.
Differentiating Similar Remedies
Observation in homeopathy helps distinguish similar remedies by noting subtle nuances, characteristic expressions, and qualitative aspects of symptoms. Physical traits, like body type and complexion, offer initial clues (e.g., Calcarea Carbonica for “fat, fair, and flabby” people, Bryonia for “robust, firm-fibred, dark-complexioned” individuals, and Phosphorus for “tall, slender, narrow-chested” ones). More precise differentiation comes from observing patient narratives and behaviors. For instance, feelings of victimization with defensive anger may suggest an animal-kingdom remedy, and unique traits—such as a fondness for black pepper—can further confirm a choice like Lac caninum.
Assessing Prognosis and Treatment Response
Observation continues after prescribing to evaluate prognosis and remedy action. Changes in mental state are especially important, often indicating deep-level improvement.
Conclusion
By uniting mental, emotional, and physical observations, homeopaths craft individualized treatments that address the whole person. Observation is more than collecting symptoms—it’s an interpretive art vital for differentiating remedies and understanding the patient’s unique constitution. A refined observational skill allows practitioners to construct the “totality of symptoms” essential for accurate prescribing and holistic healing.
1. Dr. G. Nagendra Babu- Comprehensive study of organon – an attempt to understand the organon of medicine as a scientific treatise- B. Jain Publishers- 2018
2. Dr. Stuart Close- The Genius Of Homoeopathy- lectures and essays on homoeopathic philosophy- B. Jain Publishers – 2020
3. Dr. James Tyler Kent- Lectures on Homoeopathic Philosophy with classroom notes and word index- B. Jain Publishers- 2019
4. Dr. S. Hahnemann- organon of medicine with additions & alterations of 6th edition –B. Jain Publsihers
5. Dr. Herbert A. Roberts – the principles & art of cure by homoeopathy- 3rd edition
6. Dr. Vrishti goel, Dr. Rahul kumar Chauhan, Dr. Ritu gontiya- listening to little voices: unlocking healing through pediatric homeoeopathic case taking – international journal of homoeopathic sciences
7. Dr. Ramanlal P Patel- the art of case taking and practical repertorisation in homoeopathy- 6th edition- 1998
8. Dr. Sumit Goel- a study on organon of medicine and homoeopathic philosophy- indian books & periodical publishers
9. The academic- An Online Peer Reviewed / Refereed Journal Volume 2 | Issue 8 | August 2024 ISSN: 2583-973X (Online) -Dr. Kamei Dijinlung Rongmei, Dr.Priyanka Hawaibam and Dr. Laishram Bhagat Singh
10. Dr Simon Chadwick Power of Observation podcast March 2014
