ABTRACT
OBJECTIVE: This research aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of Plantago major in two homeopathic preparations – 30 Ch potency and mother tincture – for treating toothache. MATERIALAND METHOD: The study involved 40 patients from a homeopathic medical college and its outreach camps. They were treated with either the mother tincture (PMMT) or the 30 Ch potency (PM 30CH) of Plantago major. The severity of their toothache was monitored based on homeopathic principles. CONCLSUION: The study concluded that both the mother tincture and the 30 Ch potency of Plantago major were effective in reducing toothache severity. Statistical analysis indicated no significant demographic differences between the treatment groups, ensuring a fair comparison. While both treatments showed positive outcomes, the 30 Ch potency demonstrated a slightly better average reduction in pain and more consistent results compared to the mother tincture. Overall, the study suggests that while both preparations of Plantago major can help alleviate toothache, the 30 Ch potency may offer MORE advantage in terms of effectiveness and consistency.
INTRODUCTION
The foundation of oral health lies in understanding the intricate structure of teeth. The outermost layer, enamel, stands as the body’s hardest substance, a crystalline shield of hydroxyapatite protecting the tooth’s crown. Beneath this lies dentin, a calcified tissue forming the bulk of the tooth. The pulp, the tooth’s innermost sanctuary, houses vital nerves
and blood vessels extending through the root canals. Anchoring the tooth to the jawbone is cementum, a softer calcified layer covering the roots, facilitated by periodontal ligaments. The surrounding gingiva, or gums, plays a crucial role in maintaining the integrity of the tooth’s support.1
Humans possess four primary types of teeth, each specialized for a stage in food processing. Incisors, the sharp front teeth, excel at cutting. Pointed canines are designed for tearing. Premolars, with their ridged, flat surfaces, crush food. Finally, molars, the largest back teeth with multiple cusps, are the powerhouses for grinding food into digestible particles. The emergence of wisdom teeth, or third molars, can sometimes present complications due to limited space. Dentists utilize the Universal Numbering System (UNS), a standardized method of labeling teeth from 1 to 32, ensuring clear communication in dental care.2
Numerous factors can compromise dental health. Tooth decay, or cavities, arises from bacterial acid erosion of enamel and dentin. Gum disease, a bacterial infection of the supporting tissues, can lead to inflammation and eventual tooth loss.Tooth sensitivity occurs when the protective enamel wears away, exposing the underlying dentin and nerves to stimuli. Physical trauma can result in tooth fractures, ranging from minor chips to severe breaks. A tooth abscess, a pus-filled pocket due to bacterial infection, can cause significant pain and complications. Bruxism, or teeth grinding, often during sleep, can wear down teeth and cause fractures. Lastly, tooth erosion, the gradual loss of enamel due to acids, increases sensitivity and decay risk. Specific triggers for tooth sensitivity include aggressive brushing, receding gums, decay, cracks, and acidic foods and drinks.3,4
The study of epidemiology of toothache reveals its widespread occurrence across ages and demographics, influenced by socioeconomic factors and access to care. Toothache’s diverse causes include cavities, gum disease, trauma, fractures, abscesses, impaction, and TMJ disorders. Several risk factors elevate the likelihood of toothache, such as poor oral hygiene, sugary diets, tobacco and alcohol use, systemic diseases like diabetes, genetic predispositions, and limited access to dental services. The impact on quality of life can be substantial, affecting eating, speaking, sleeping, productivity, social interactions, and psychological well-being. Health disparities exist, with certain populations disproportionately affected. Effective preventive measures emphasize good oral hygiene, balanced diets low in sugar, avoiding tobacco, using protective gear, and seeking timely dental care.5
The pathophysiology of toothache elucidates the mechanisms of dental pain. Dental caries can expose the pulp, leading to inflammation (pulpitis) and nerve stimulation. Dentin hypersensitivity arises from exposed dentinal tubules reacting to temperature or acidic stimuli. Periodontal disease inflames and infects tooth supports, potentially exposing roots. Dental trauma can directly damage the pulp or nerves. Pain from sinusitis can be referred to the teeth. Bruxism can cause enamel wear and nerve sensitivity. Accurate diagnosis and management necessitate understanding these underlying processes, with treatment focusing on addressing the root cause and alleviating symptoms.6
Conventional management of toothache often involves simple home remedies like cold compresses to numb the area and reduce inflammation, warm saltwater rinses to cleanse and soothe, avoiding trigger foods and drinks, and maintaining good oral hygiene.7
From a homeopathic point of view, toothache signifies a deeper imbalance in the body’s vital force. Treatment aims to stimulate self-healing using highly diluted remedies matching the individual’s unique symptoms and constitution. Examples include Arnica Montana for trauma, Chamomilla for shooting pain relieved by cold, Belladonna for sudden throbbing pain with redness and heat, Mercurius solubilis for pain with excessive salivation and bad breath, Hypericum perforatum for nerve pain, Plantago major for shooting pain extending to the ear, and Staphysagria for pain after dental procedures. The homeopathic approach emphasizes individualized treatment, thorough case-taking, symptom matching based on the principle of “like cures like,” potential use of adjunctive therapies, and ongoing follow-up and adjustment of treatment.8
The World Health Organization (WHO) champions oral health as integral to overall health, advocating for preventing and managing oral diseases. Their strategies include promoting good oral hygiene, reducing sugar intake, and avoiding tobacco, alongside addressing underlying factors contributing to conditions like dry mouth.9
Plantago major, or common plantain, is detailed. Botanically, it’s a robust perennial herb with distinctive leaves and flower spikes. Its historical authority in traditional medicine dates back centuries.Ancient civilizations like the Greeks and Romans used it for wound healing, inflammation, gastrointestinal issues, respiratory ailments, skin conditions, and eye irritations. In Medieval Europe, it treated skin problems and coughs. Native Americans used it for insect bites and injuries. Colonial America continued its medicinal use. Modern research has validated its anti-inflammatory, antimicrobial, and wound-healing properties, attributed to compounds like aucubin and allantoin. In dental care, Plantago major has been traditionally employed as a poultice for toothache, a mouthwash or rinse to reduce inflammation, and by chewing the leaves for temporary relief. Its anti-inflammatory and analgesic properties are believed to contribute to these effects, potentially also promoting gum health.10,11
Plantago major for Dental Problems: Specific traditional uses for toothache relief, including poultices, mouthwashes, chewing leaves, and its anti
inflammatory and analgesic properties for gum health.12
Clarke JH. A Dictionary of Practical Materia Medica.
Teeth (l.) feel elongated, sore; pain unbearably severe, boring digging in sound teeth; < from contact and extremes of heat and cold.─Aching in decayed teeth, or shooting up l. side of face; face red.─Rapid decay.─Sharp stabbing along upper maxillary nerve, < by contact.─Violent pain in l. upper molars; sound teeth; excessive boring, digging pain, profuse flow of saliva; < by walking in cold air and by contact, by much heat; partial > lying down in a moderately cool room; pain unendurable (> by Merc. 30).─Teeth sensitive, sore.─Grinds teeth at night.─Gums bleed easily.─Gumboil.
Mouth.─Tongue coated white, with dirty, putrid, clammy taste.─Food tasteless.─Breath putrid.─Aphthæ in children.13
Allen TF. Encyclopaedia of pure Materia Medica.
Teeth of left side feel elongated and sore; violent pains in upper molars of left side; sound teeth; excessive boring, digging pain, profuse flow of saliva; aggravated by walking in cold air and by contact; also by a high degree of heat; partial ease obtained only by lying down in a moderately cool room; could not endure the pain(14)
Boericke W. New Manual of Homoeopathic Materia Medica With Repertory, New Delhi: Indian Books and Publishers, 2013.
PLANTAGO MAJOR : Teeth ache and are sensitive and sore to touch. Swelling of cheeks. Salivation; teeth feel too long; worse, cold air and contact. Toothache, better while eating. Profuse of saliva. Toothache, with reflex neuralgia of eyelids.(15)
http://www.homeoint.org/books2/bogersyn/mmphypso.htm#plantagomaj
A SYNOPTIC KEY OF THE MATERIA MEDICA By Cyrus Maxwell BOGER
Sharp, shifting pains. Soreness. Neuralgia. As of a body between ears; in groins, etc. ……………….. As if brain turned over. As of a hair before (l),
eye. Pains center in ears and teeth or alternate between them.
Earache. Saliva flows with the pains. Toothache. Dirty taste. Bowels seem cold. Brown, frothy stools. Polyuria. Enuresis. Throbbing between scapulæ. Cold sweat on sacrum. Numb, tremulous legs. Sensitive skin. Gloomy dreams, exciting tears.(16)
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The study employed a prospective, comparative design conducted at the Government Homoeopathic Medical College and Hospital in Bhopal. Forty patients, aged 20 to 60 years of both sexes, presenting with symptoms of Plantago-related toothache and providing informed consent, were recruited. Patients allergic to Plantago major, those concurrently receiving other toothache treatments, or individuals with significant untreated medical or dental conditions that could confound the study were excluded. Participants were randomly assigned to one of two treatment groups: one receiving Plantago major 30th potency and the other receiving Plantago major mother tincture, both dispensed from the hospital’s dispensing unit. Pain levels were assessed using the Visual Analog Scale (VAS). Follow-up assessments were conducted after one week. Data collected on standard case-taking proformas were analyzed using chi-square and paired t-tests in SPSS v21.0, with a p-value of <0.05 considered statistically significant.
VISUAL ANALOGOUS SCALE for pain:
NO MILD PAIN MODERATE PAIN SEVERE PAIN WORST PAIN
PAIN
NO PAIN MILD PAIN MODERATE PAIN NO PAIN MILD
The VAS scale, or Visual Analog Scale, is a tool used to measure subjective experiences such as pain, discomfort, or other sensations. It typically consists of a straight line, usually 10 cm long, where one end represents “no pain” or “no discomfort” and the other end represents “worst possible pain” or “worst possible discomfort.”
How it works:
The Scale: The line is marked with endpoints, such as 0 (no pain) and 10 (worst pain imaginable).
Assessment: The person being assessed marks a point on the line that corresponds to their level of pain or discomfort.
Measurement: The distance from the “no pain” end to the mark indicates the intensity of the sensation. This distance is usually measured in centimeters or millimeters.
The VAS scale is widely used in clinical settings because it is simple, quick, and easy to understand, making it useful for tracking changes in pain levels over time or in response to treatment.
DISCUSSION
Both treatments (PMMT and PM30CH) appear effective in reducing toothache severity. The analysis shows that there is a significant reduction in pain, but the variability in effectiveness suggests that individual responses may vary. The potency data showed a slightly better average outcome, but the differences are not dramatic.
SUMMARY
The Prospective and Comparative study was design to know the effectiveness of case Plantago Major mother tincture and 30Ch potency in Toothache patient.
The study was done at college OPD of Government Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital Bhopal and its attenuates. For the study 40 patients screened the data was recorded on standard case taking properly. Patients were distributed to simple randomization method and medicine was given each group
Methodology: Patients were divided into two groups to receive PMMT or PM30CH. The study evaluated multiple demographic and lifestyle factors to ensure that these did not confound the results, including age, gender, diet, addiction, lifestyle, duration of toothache, dwelling place, and socioeconomic status.
CONCLUSION
Both treatments resulted in a reduction in toothache severity, with the potency data showing slightly better average results and less variability.
Overall, while both treatments show efficacy in reducing toothache severity, the potency treatment demonstrates a marginally higher average effectiveness with more consistent
outcomes. This suggests that the potency treatment may be slightly more effective, but both treatments are generally successful in alleviating toothache.
BIBLIOGRAPHY VANCOUVER STYLE
1. Campista HC, Matos JDM, Queiroz DA, Maciel LC. DENTAL ANATOMY AND MORPHOLOGY. Open access publication by Atena Editora. 2023 Mar. DOI: 10.22533/at.ed.298230903.page 1, 5. Available from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/369135119_Dental_anatomy_and_morpholo gy
2. Campista HC, Matos JDM, Queiroz DA, Maciel LC. DENTAL ANATOMY AND MORPHOLOGY. Open access publication by Atena Editora. 2023 Mar. DOI: 10.22533/at.ed.298230903.page 11. Available from :
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/369135119_Dental_anatomy_and_morpholo gy
3:Sheikh Z. Slideshow: 15 tooth problems [Internet]. WebMD; 2023 Sep 22. Available from: https://www.webmd.com/oral-health/ss/slideshow-tooth-problems
4. Absi EG, Addy M, Adams D. Dentine hypersensitivity: A study of the patency of dentinal tubules in sensitive and non-sensitive cervical dentine. J Clin Periodontol. 1987 May;14(5):280-4. Available from: onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1600- 051X.1987.tb01533.x
5. Hahnemann S. Organon der Heilkunst (Organon of the Art of Healing). 4th ed. Translated by Devrient CH. Germany: W.F. Wakeman; 1833. AVAILABLE FROM: https://www.homeopathyschool.com/the-school/editorial/the-organon/
6. Slade GD. Epidemiology of dental pain and dental caries among children and adolescents. Community Dent Health. 2001 Dec;18(4):219-27. PMID: 11789699. Available from: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11789699/
7. Kutsch VK. Balance: A Guide to Managing Dental Caries for Patients and Practitioner
. English ed. ISBN-10: 1605949647, ISBN-13: 978-1605949642. P-AGE :12,15.
8. Plantago Major. In: Homoeopathic Materia Medica [Internet]. Homéopathe International; [cited 2024 Oct 15]. Available from: http://www.homeoint.org/books/boericmm/plan
9. Oral health. World Health Organization (WHO) [Internet]. [cited 2024 Oct 15]. Available from: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/oral-health
10. Homoeopathic Pharmacopoeia of India [Internet]. ABFH; [cited 2024 Oct 15]. Available from: https://abfh.org.br/HPI-COMBIND-VOLUME-I-V (vol-II) PAGE: 577-578
11. Central Council for Research in Homoeopathy. A Handbook of Medicinal Plants Used in Homoeopathy. 2018. New Delhi: Central Council for Research in Homoeopathy; 304 p.
12.Clarke JH. Plantago. In: Materia Medica [Internet]. Free Materia Medica Books; [cited 2024 Oct 15]. Available from: https://www.materiamedica.info/materia-medica/plant
13. Clarke JH. A dictionary of practical materia medica. New Delhi: B. Jain Publishers Pvt. Ltd; 1995. Available from: http://www.homeoint.org/clarke/p/plant.htm
14. Allen TF. Encyclopaedia of pure materia medica. New Delhi: B. Jain Publishers Pvt. Ltd; 1995. Available from: http://www.homeoint.org/allen/p/plan-2.htm
15. Boericke W. New manual of homoeopathic materia medica with repertory. New Delhi: Indian Books and Publishers; 2013. Available from:
http://www.homeoint.org/books/boericmm/p/plan.htm
16. Boger CM. A synoptic key of the materia medica. Available from:
http://www.homeoint.org/books2/bogersyn/mmphypso.htm#plantagomaj
.
