Abstract: Placing centesimal potencies in solution and prescribing them frequently for acute conditions is not widely practiced. It can be superior to dry doses in many cases, where a persistent mild medicinal action is preferred to a strong aggravation. By prescribing dissolved doses of Arnica Montana 1m, a case of acute appendicitis was cured quickly. This suggests that centesimal potencies given frequently in solution may be more efficacious, prompt and gentle than treatment with dry doses.
When treating a patient with acute medical condition, in certain cases we fail to cure. Even though our case taking, evaluation, analysis, remedy and potency selection seem correct. What is the cause? In the Organon 5th edition (1833) Dr. Hahnemann introduced olfaction and dissolved centesimal remedies as a new method of administering doses. Around the year 1840 Hahnemann began to introduce LM potencies into his practice. From 1840 to 1843 he used both centesimal and LM potencies side by side in medicinal solutions. By these methods he hoped to avoid unwanted aggravations and provide rapid cure.
In some acute cases the aggravation can be discouragingly prolonged and often cannot be discerned from the patient’s own disease. Many times we change the original prescription which could very well have been the simillimum. In acute diseases, a dry dose will many times produce an unnecessary aggravation because of the patient’s increased susceptibility. I have much experience now with what I call a “watery dose.” To prepare it, one or two globules of size 10 are diluted in 15ml. of distilled water in which 5 drops of alcohol added with 20 to 30 succussions. From this solution 10 drops are added to another 15 ml of water, and from this solution 5 to 10 drops dose repeated according to the severity of the disease. In such diluted solutions the correct number of drops must be precise. Every time before taking the dose the solution is succussed 5 to 10 times. The same solution can be used for several days or weeks. Hahnemann recommended using carefully measured and dosed solutions with sensitive patients. Many times I have used this method with great success. It is not necessary to take 4 oz. to 8 oz. of water, Just fifteen ml. of distilled water is sufficient. This technique of dosing is also known as a split dose because it uses one or two pills in a solution that is then split over several days or weeks.
The results using this type of dosing can be very different from dry doses. There is continuous amelioration of the complaints without aggravation. This comes closer to the ideal of strengthening the weakened vital force than is seen when we simply produce a similar stronger artificial disease in the patient.
Name: Mr. B.B.
Date: 23rd may 2014
Marital Status: Married
Severe cramping pain in right iliac fossa since 3 days.
<Sneezing, coughing, breathing and slightest movement.
Fullness of abdomen aggravated by eating smallest quantity of food.
Onset, duration and Progress
Patient was apparently well before 8 days but suddenly he was injured by a bull. Due to which he was fall on back and started backache. For that he had taken allopathic medicines. After 4 days backache was better and the right sided abdominal pain started. For that he was consulted to a surgeon. Ultra sonography report shows acute appendicitis. Surgeon advised him for immediate surgery.
Patient as a Person
General appearance: Stout with round face.
Weight: 68 kg.
Addictions: Tobacco Eliminations:
Stool pattern: Satisfactory
Sleep and dreams: sleepless since 3 days.
Past History: Unremarkable
Family History: Not specific
Anxious about his disease.
Restlessness from pain.
Fear of operation.
Abdomen- Hard, Tenderness in right iliac fossa.
All the other systems are within normal limits.
- Ailments from injury.
- Restlessness pain from.
- Pain cramping in right hypochondria.
- Pain aggravated by motion.
- Abdomen distention painful.
- Abdomen fullness aggravated by eating.
- Diagnosis: Acute appendicitis
- Phase of disease: Acute progressive
- Miasm: Psora
- Susceptibility: Moderate
Selection of Remedy:
Without repertorisation Arnica Montana 1m was selected due to prominent exciting cause. It is given in “watery doses”- 10 drops at 15 minutes interval.
Preparation of dose: Two globules of size 10 pellets diluted in 15 ml of distilled water in a dropper bottle, adding 5 drops of alcohol then succussed 20 to 30 times. From this solution 10 drops added to another 15 ml of water in a dropper bottle. From this solution 10 drops on the tongue taken every 15 minute after giving 10 succussions to the bottle.
Follow-up: 24 May, 2014
By the first dose which was given at 7p.m. on 23rd may 2014 within 5 to 10 minute he feels comfort in the abdomen. After repetition of doses in one hour pain was relieved. He had taken his dinner well without any fullness and he slept well at night. Today he has no any abdominal symptoms but backache is more which was occur due to fall on back.
Same watery doses of Arnica Montana 1m continued 3 times a day for 8 days.
Follow-up: 30 May, 2014
Backache better. No any abdominal symptoms. Appetite increased.
Prescription: Sac lac for 15days.
By using no other treatment than homoeopathic Arnica montana1m dissolved in water, given in frequent drop doses, a case of acute appendicitis was cured. This suggests that the use of frequent watery doses, described in Organon 6th edition may be more efficacious, prompt and gentle than treatment with dry doses.
I express my gratitude to Dr. Arun Bhasme sir Principal S.K.H.M.C.Beed & Dr. Sandeep Narwadkar Principal P.D.Jain H.M.C.Parbhani for their valuable suggestions.
1] Hanemann S., Organon of medicine ,6th edition. Translated by W.Boerick, B.Jain Publishers (P) Ltd.: New Delhi.
2] Schepper L.D., Hahnemannian Textbook of Classical Homeopathy for the Professional, B. Jain Publishers (P) Ltd: reprint edition 2005-06
3] Schepper L.D., Achieving and Maintaining the Similimum, B.Jain Publishers (P) Ltd.: reprint edition 200-06
4] Hahnemann S, The Chronic Diseases; B.Jain Publishers (P) Ltd., New Delhi.
5] Davidson et al., Principles and Practice of Medicine,18th edition; Published by Edinburgh London;New york.